A young Batavia mother who was among the first people in the state charged under Leandra's Law for driving under the influence with children in the car will spend a year in jail for violating probation by allegedly driving drunk again.
Michelle T. Crawford, 26, of 7963 Batavia Stafford Townline Road, sobbed throughout the court proceedings this morning and asked Judge Robert C. Noonan for another chance at rehabilitation.
Besides the violation of probation conviction, Crawford is still facing charges that she drove drunk March 8 and was involved in a rollover accident in Byron. Crawford was seriously injured in the accident and had her jaw wired shut for a period of time as a result.
Crawford was on probation, having recently completed one alcohol treatment program, at the time of the accident. While she wasn't convicted under Leandra's Law on the prior case, which was heard in Erie County, Crawford was found guilty of driving under the influence and three counts of endangering the welfare of a child.
In court today, Crawford's attorney said his client has a serious drinking problem and needs treatment, not jail time.
"Jail isn't going to fix Ms. Crawford," Attorney Louis P. Violanti said. "I realize society may demand jail time, but without treatment, she's going to end up doing life on the installment plan, one year at a time, three years at a time, until one day she wakes up and she's in her 60s and her life is gone and her children are grown."
Violanti said Crawford was recently accepted to an in-patient program and that her rehabilitation would be a long-term process.
When Crawford spoke, she cried through all of her statement.
"If I don't get this under my thumb, I'm never going to have my family," Crawford said. "Please let me be able to do this. Please from the bottom of my heart. I'm a good person. I just made poor choices and I just want to go home to my family and the people that I love. And I want to prove that I can be successful in life and not be harmful to anybody else, including myself."
Noonan said if Crawford was appearing before him for just the first time he would be a lot more sympathetic to her plea to be with her children, but Crawford promised Noonan once before, he said, to follow the orders of the court and then apparently violated them.
"You're very lucky you didn't kill a family or somebody else in your alcoholic stupor," Noonan said. "Now you must face the consequences.
"We're all very interested in doing something that will get Michelle Crawford going in the right direction in life," Noonan added, "but right now you must be punished."
The year in jail -- Crawford has already served about three months -- is the maximum penalty under the sentencing guidelines for her misdemeanor convictions.
Crawford still faces a misdemeanor DWI charge and a felony count of aggravated unlicensed operation.
Noonan said he and the attorneys are trying to come up with a plan for Crawford on those charges that will satisfy justice and get her help.
I do appreciate the fact that
I do appreciate the fact that Ms. Crawford won't necessarily get the help she needs in prison, but - 1) this is not her first offense of this nature, 2) it obviously was serious as reflected in her injuries, and 3) there were children in the car - I find no excuse for drinking and driving with innocent children in the car. I hope that Ms. Crawford does get the help she needs - not only for herself, but for her children.
Jail might not fix her
Jail might not fix her drinking problem but she won't be able to hurt anyone else while she's in there. Suck it up, do the time and stop whining about it.
She can at least get a jump
She can at least get a jump start on the drinking problem, they don't serve alcohol in jail, and I think most jails allow AA to visit inmates who are interested.
A stint in prison might do
A stint in prison might do her some good.
After sentencing, she would be sent to Albion or Bedford Hills and processed. She would be interviewed, assigned a counselor and then given the opportunity to participate in the very good mandatory drug /substance abuse rehabilitation treatment programs offered. There are AA Chapters in New York State Correctional Facilities.
Like anything else in life, you get what you put into it, and yes, Doug is right; suck it up and deal with it.
Richard, She gets one(1) year
Richard,
She gets one(1) year on this conviction, so she will be sent to a County jail on this.
John, Yes, thank you, I read
John,
Yes, thank you, I read that. The point is she would receive the necessary treatment in prison. See post #2.