Skip to main content

Consultant's memo makes clear, sale not the only option being considered for nursing home

By Howard B. Owens

The county wants to look at a range of options for dealing with its financially troubled nursing home, according to a memo written by a consultant the county plans to hire.

The scope of work planned by the Center for Governmental Research in Rochester is detailed in a memo from its director of human services analysis, Donald E. Pryor. The memo was released at the Ways and Means Committee meeting on Wednesday.

The study will involve numerous interviews with key stakeholders, an examination of past operational and financial history and comparisons with other facilities around the state.

CGR will look at least a dozen options for changing the status of the nursing home, including both keeping the operation as it is or selling it. Even closing it will be an option considered.

"CGR now understands clearly that the County is not currently considering the 'sell' option, and that there are many options that you wish to explore in more detail before you do consider that option, if you indeed ever do," Pryor writes.

"Thus this memo reframes the original proposal in that spirit, with the intent of exploring the implications, pro and con, of a number of options the County may wish to consider along a continuum of possible change, ranging from no change (status quo) to closure of the Nursing Home facility, and many options in between."

Among the other options Pryor discusses are bed licenses to a third-party operator, conversion of the nursing home to a free-standing, not-for-profit facility, renegotiating agreements with the employees union, creation of a public benefits corporation, and better marketing of the facility.

"Rather than focus on an RFP process designed to determine the possible interest and viability of entities who may be interested in the possibility of purchasing the County Nursing Home, our revised proposal deletes all reference to that RFP process," Pryor writes. "Instead, the focus of this revised proposal is on an objective assessment of the strengths, limitations and overall implications of a wide range of options for the operation, management and possible disposition of the Nursing Home and its companion Adult Home."

The memo was part of the final contract provided to the Ways and Means Committee for review and approval. The committee unanimously approved sending the contract to the full legislature for review and possible approval.

The memo states that the $62,000 consulting fee will cover all in costs, including travel and any other expenses.

For previous nursing home coverage, click here.

Bea McManis

Doesn't this fly in the face of one legislator who proclaimed that the sale of the nursing home was a 'done deal'?
Taking the RFP off the table is the right thing.

Apr 8, 2010, 5:52am Permalink
Dave Olsen

Sounds like an intelligent examining of the facts and options, which is what is needed. It does make me question, if Chris Charvella and his "Stop The Sale..." group didn't make it an issue, would we actually be looking at all options? Guess we'll never know.

Apr 8, 2010, 8:12am Permalink
Bea McManis

Dave,
I would like to think that "Stop the Sale.." had a great deal to do with the fact that all options are open now.
As I stated before, this is a far cry from hearing, "it's a done deal".

Apr 8, 2010, 8:27am Permalink
Chris Charvella

We've come a long way from the day Assistant County manager Frank Ciacca told local reporters that sale 'is definitely the direction we're going in.'

I'm loving this new tone coming out of the county government, but don't think for a second that we're letting our guard down. I'm looking forward to seeing a lot of my friends and fellow concerned citizens at the next legislature meeting.

Apr 8, 2010, 10:26pm Permalink

Authentically Local