Anthony Haitz as King John earns a 2024 Best Male Lead Performance in a Play Harvie Award. File Photo by Howard Owens
Batavia Players' annual Harvie Awards gala culminated in two ties, Maia Zerillo stealing the show with Best Performance, downtown's Business Improvement District getting a nod for Community Partner, and several others earning rightful recognition for their roles in productions throughout the 2024 Main St. 56 Theater season.
And the Batavia Players – Main St. 56 Theater 2024 Harvie Awards went to:
2024 Best Male Lead Performance in a Play
Anthony Haitz – King John
2024 Best Female Lead Performance in a Play
Sophie Houseman - Pygmalion
2024 Best Male Supporting Performance in a Play
Steven Coburn - Pygmalion
2024 Best Female Supporting Performance in a Play
Dorothy Gerhart – Whirligig of Time
2024 Best Male Featured Performance in a Play
Elijah Van Epps - Pygmalion
2024 Best Female Featured Performance in a Play
Sophie Houseman – Whirligig of Time
2024 Best Male Lead Performance in a Musical: a tie
Anthony Haitz – White Christmas
Elijah Van Epps – Evita
2024 Best Female Lead Performance in a Musical
Kristin Gelia – Evita
2024 Best Male Supporting Performance in a Musical: a tie
Robert Balbick – White Christmas
Skylar Dence - Evita
2024 Best Female Supporting Performance in a Musical
Teressa Hirsch – White Christmas
2024 Best Male Featured Performance in a Musical
Bill Moon – White Christmas
2024 Best Female Featured Performance in a Musical
Rory Van Epps - Evita
2024 Best Male Performance in a Cabaret
Deacon Smith – Four the Record
2024 Best Female Featured Performance in a Cabaret
Jocelyn Coburn – Four the Record
2024 Best Group Performance in a Cabaret
This Man – Just One More Time
2024 Best Solo Performance in a Cabaret
Ian Cannioto – Wickedly Musical
2024 Best Youth Performance in a Cabaret
Lilah Mordell – Wickedly Musical
2024 Best Youth Performance in a Musical or Play
Maia Zerillo – Bye Bye Birdie
2024 Best Child Performance in a Musical or Play
Elle Williams – White Christmas
2024 Best Solo Performance in a Musical
Kristin Gelia – Don’t Cry For Me Argentina
2024 Best Group Performance in a Musical
And the Money Kept Rolling in - Evita
2024 Performance of the Year
Maia Zerillo - Bye Bye Birdie
2024 Director of the Year
James Chamberlain
2024 Community Partner of the Year
Downtown Batavia Business Improvement District
File Photo of Maia Zerillo in "Bye Bye Birdie." Photo by Howard Owens.
File Photo of Kristin Gelia, who won the Best Female Lead Performance in a Musical for her role in "Evita." Photo by Howard Owens.
File Photo of Maia Zerillo in "Bye Bye Birdie" Photo by Howard Owens
As the saying goes, the show — or, in this case, the awards gala — must go on no matter what.
And no matter if there hasn’t been a definitive answer to Batavia Players’ third attempt to fulfill the city’s request for a five-year financial plan to pay rent and pay back rent owed, the group is preparing for its Harvie Awards gala later next month, Patrick Burk says.
"I have not heard from the city. I think the last letter that we got from the city was an explanation of what they were required to make a decision, and that was on December 19. We have sent them a number of pages of information, including our budget,” Burk said Monday. “You know, we have been working on making sure that we are attempting a plan to pay that COVID rent back; even though many people are questioning why we have to pay rent when we weren't allowed to go into the facility, we still just want to get on with what we do best, which is entertaining people and providing theater. And we're doing that very successfully.
“It's important for people to understand that we've been paying all of our bills. We owe nobody, every single month we've paid every single bill,” he said. “We've made arrangements for things to be paid on a timely basis, and we're doing our best with everything, including sell-out shows, and more audience members and bigger box office numbers than we've ever seen before.”
The five-year plan was requested as part of a resolution to the Players owing back rent for its new theater, which was shut down due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The theater folks have said it was difficult to raise revenue during a time when they weren’t even allowed in the building to put on a show and charge admission.
Meanwhile, city officials and the theater’s landlord have said there are still operating and maintenance expenses and that unpaid bills end up costing taxpayers. City Council President Eugene Jankowski has said that no one is against the theater but that the tab does have to be paid, and he’s hoping a solution can be found.
During council’s Dec. 10 conference meeting, two representatives of Batavia Players spoke about the attributes of their organization and asked that city leaders give them some time and understanding to pay back the money. City Manager Rachael Tabelski said the owed amount was approximately $27,000.
“We are awaiting an executive summary and five-year financial projections of the Players' plan moving forward,” she had said.
The lease expires on Wednesday, Jan. 1.
Burk is taking the contract to its word that the lease is “automatically renewed” on the first of the year, he said. Since he hasn’t heard from the city otherwise, plans are already being made for three events in January, including the 2025 Pure Imagination Harvie Awards Gala.
“We’re just going through that it's automatically renewed. I don't know what else we can do. Again, I only want to provide good entertainment shows. We've got a lot of things planned for the coming year; we're going to be announcing a new season relatively soon. We're working on securing that, like, right after the first of the year so that we can make a definitive announcement at the gala,” he said. “We've already started with programs in January that are not season-related. We have three weekends, the 11th, the 18th and the 25th, where things are going on at the theater. Two of them are from outside groups, and our gala is going to be wonderful.”
Set for 7 p.m. Jan. 11 at Main St. 56 Theater in Batavia City Centre, this annual event recognizes and honors exceptional talents of actors showcasedin Batavia Players productions from throughout the past year. Awards are given in several categories for male and female lead and supporting performances, venues of plays, cabarets, musicals, and from child to adult actors.
One of the angriest of the "12 Angry Jurors," Teressa Hirsch earned a nomination for Lead Actress in a Play for her unflinching character. File Photo by Howard Owens
As another year begins to fade away in the hopefulness of a new one, there’s still room for a look back at the best and brightest theatrical performances as the Batavia Players present the 2024 Gala: Starting Here, Starting Now!
The premise is simple enough. Pat Burk says: it’s a new year, the first time for the awards show in a brand new theater, and with all but three of a dozen new shows negotiated for the 2024 season.
“Starting Here, Starting Now is a song written for a musical, it’s not really well known, but it’s about, this is the beginning of our new year, it’s about things being new. It’s just a nice kind of event, and people can see the seating and the style in the theater and how things are presented there. And it’s just kind of a cool event,” Burk said during an interview with The Batavian. “We’re pretty close to being completed, and all of our shows will be presented in the same venue with all new equipment. It’s just going to be a great year for us.”
Set for 7 p.m. Saturday at the Main St. 56 Theater in downtown Batavia, the gala is a party celebration of the Players’ “very successful 2023 season” with hors d’oeuvres, refreshments, basket raffles, select performances and — drum roll, please — a presentation of the 2023 Harvie Awards to a slate of deserving performers in this past year’s lineup of shows.
There will be several recap performances and highlights of plays and musicals from the past season, along with a discussion about why people were nominated and ultimately chosen for each award.
Directors from each of the shows submitted nominations, and four additional directors contributed reviews for the final selections, Burk said. Beyond a nod of recognition for the talent up on stage is a moment to pause and reflect and reminisce about the seven musicals and four play productions put forth in a span of 12 months, he said.
This will be the first time since COVID — will it ever be forgotten? — for a full-blown awards show. The last one was for the 2019 awards, and it was right smack in the middle of a St. Patrick’s holiday that health department officials came in to shut down the event on those first bleak days of the pandemic, he said.
“And they came in nicely, and we said, ‘Can we at least finish, or can we get the food out of here?’ And they said we had to close up. I remember they allowed us to do takeout containers for the corned beef and cabbage,” he said.
Does that feel like a million years ago now, or yesterday?
“A million years ago, because we were also in the process of just starting the demolition of the new theater. And that literally started that January 1, and we were just so looking forward to, within two years, we’d be out of Harvester and into our new theater. And obviously, none of that happened,” he said. “So, we’re in the new theater … it’s so deserved. It’s been a long time coming.”
And in that vein, the theater is starting here, starting now, with its 2024 season that kicks off with a concert, “Pushin’ Time,” with duo Eric Carlin and Deanna Spiotta Carlin on Jan. 19. Other confirmed shows include “The Little Mermaid Jr.," “Pygmalion,” and one that Burk is thrilled to have secured for May, Andrew Lloyd Webber’s “Evita.”
As for the remainder of the lineup, that will be revealed, except for those three shows still in negotiations, during this weekend's gala. Attendees may want to spiff up for the affair if they like and absorb a medley of productions while supporting the arts and artists who make it happen.
Admission is a $30 donation. Advance ticket purchases are encouraged at bataviaplayers.org
Award nominations went to the following:
Lead actor in a play
Stephen VanValkenburg - Almost Maine
Steven Coburn - Antony & Cleopatra
Steven Coburn - 12 Angry Jurors
Anthony Haitz - One Act Plays/The Bear
Seth Coburn - One Act Plays/Mr. Icky
Lead actress in a play
Jacqueline Morrison - Almost Maine
Emily Crawford - Antony & Cleopatra
Teressa Hirsch - 12 Angry Jurors
Teressa Hirsch - One act plays/Verbatim
Supporting actor in a play
Elijah Van Epps - Almost Maine
Shaun Coburn - Almost Maine
Elijah Van Epps - Antony & Cleopatra
James Barcomb - 12 Angry Jurors
James Barcomb - One act plays/The Bear
Supporting actress in a play
Kendra Morrison - Almost Maine
Cynthia Nelson - Almost Maine
Cynthia Nelson - Antony & Cleopatra
Dorothy Gerhart - 12 Angry Jurors
Dorothy Gerhart - One act plays/Verbatim
Featured actor in a play
Richard Ferris - Almost Maine
Lawrence Rowswell - Antony & Cleopatra
James Barcomb - Antony & Cleopatra
Anthony Haitz - 12 Angry Jurors
Shakeem Walcott - One act plays/Mr. Icky
Featured actress in a play
Sophie Houseman - Almost Maine
Maia Zerillo - Almost Maine
Erin Stamp - Antony & Cleopatra
Shellene Bailey - Antony & Cleopatra
Mary Eckstein - 12 Angry Jurors
Sophie Crandall - One act plays/Mr. Icky
Leading male performance in a musical
Marc Sapareto - Opposites Attract
Phil Berry - Drowsy Chaperone
Marc Sapareto - Do Not Sing List
Marc Sapareto - Cry Baby
Kevin Partridge - A Christmas Carol
Leading female performance in a musical
Sarah Hill - Opposites Attract
Kristin Gelia - Drowsy Chaperone
Maia Zerillo - Do Not Sing List
Maia Zerillo - Cry Baby
Jennifer Dunn - A Christmas Carol
Supporting male performance in a musical
Seth Coburn - Opposites Attract
Sam Bowman - Drowsy Chaperone
Qasim Huzair - Drowsy Chaperone
Deacon Smith - Do Not Sing List
Deacon Smith - Cry Baby
Andy Hamm - A Christmas Carol
Supporting female performance in a musical
Jocelyn Coburn - Opposites Attract
Sophie Houseman - Drowsy Chaperone
Kendra Morrison - Do Not Sing List
Paige Sikorski - Cry Baby
Rose Mosher - Cry Baby
Amanda Melissa Taylor - A Christmas Carol
Featured male performance in a musical
Cass Dzielski - Opposites Attract
Anthony Haitz - Drowsy Chaperone
Steven Coburn - Drowsy Chaperone
Elijah Van Epps - Do Not Sing List
Paul Daniszewski - Cry Baby
William Zerillo - A Christmas Carol
Featured female performance in a musical
Teressa Hirsch - Opposites Attract
Amy-Catherine - Cunningham Drowsy Chaperone
Beth Knopf - Drowsy Chaperone
Kristin Gelia - Do Not Sing List
Samantha Jane Balbi -Cry Baby
Kylea Wright - Cry Baby
Dorothy Gerhart - A Christmas Carol
Youth performance
Peyton Woeller -Do Not Sing List
Quinn Boardman - All Shook Up
Peyton Sikorski - All Shook Up
Peyton Woeller - Cry Baby
Sophie Crandall - A Christmas Carol
Lilah Mordell - A Christmas Carol
Child performance
Annalie Crandall - All Shook Up
Sylar Kuenzi - All Shook Up
Adam Jursted - Cry Baby
Xavier Deschamps - A Christmas Carol
Liam Taylor - A Christmas Carol
Charlotte Reddin - A Christmas Carol
Best musical performance ensemble
Move Towards the Darkness - Opposites Attract
I Do, I Do in the Sky - Drowsy Chaperone
Cell Block Tango -Do Not Sing List
You Bet Your Ass - Cry Baby
In December - A Christmas Carol
Best musical performance solo
Jacqueline Morrison - Three Days Without Breathing/Opposites Attract
Sophie Houseman - As We Stumble Along/Drowsy Chaperone
Cass Dzielski - Run Away With Me/Do Not Sing List
Paige Sikorski - Screwloose/Cry Baby
Deacon Smith - Hallelujah/A Christmas Carol
Deacon Smith has been nominated for Supporting Male Performance in a Musical for his role in "Cry Baby." File Photo by Howard Owens
"Do Not Sing List " featured Peyton Woeller, front in plaid, who has been nominated for the Youth Performance category for his role. File Photo by Nick Serrata
Steven Coburn, nominated in 12 Angry Jurors. Photo by Howard Owens.
James Barcomb, nominated in One Act Plays/The Bear. Photo by Howard Owens.
