It's that time of the year when people start thinking about the holidays -- planning parties, family gatherings, gift-giving, and maybe how we might take care of ourselves and the people we love a little better.
It makes it a good time to show a little love to our community and support the local business owners who do so much to make our community a better place to live. They create jobs, serve volunteer organizations, make donations to various groups and charities, and give a local community its vibrancy.
When planning your holiday season, don't forget to support local businesses. Counties with strong local business communities thrive.
Local news is also important to the health of a local community.
Here is a list of the businesses that support The Batavian's mission to bring you lots of local news. Please remember to support them not only during the holiday season but throughout the year.
Byron-Bergen beat Cuba-Rushford/Hinsdale 4-0 on Wednesday night at Geneseo in the Class C crossover game.
The Bees now advance to the Far West Regional to take on Wilson, the Section VI Class C champ, in the Far West Championship at 5 p.m. on Friday at West Seneca Senior High School.
All four goals for the Bees were scored by Jack Farner (#8). Assists went to Colin Martin, Noah Clare, Braedyn Chambry and Cody Carlson.
Byron-Bergen's Victoria Rogoyski fouled early in the first half. Photo by Howard Owens
With each of the first two goals the Holley Hawks scored, the Byron-Bergen Bees had an answer to tie the game, but in overtime, the Hawk's third overtime goal ended the game and ended the Bees' hope of advancing further this postseason.
Byron-Byron Bergen lost the Class C crossover game at Geneseo High School and the right to play in the Western Regional Championship to Holly 3-2.
For more photos and to purchase prints, click here.
Keeper Novalee Pocock with a saver in the first half. Photo by Howard Owens
MacKenzie Hagen Photo by Howard Owens
The Holly Hawks score their first goal in the first half. Photo by Howard Owens
Mia Gray after a successful steal in the first half. Photo by Howard Owens
Ava Goff Photo by Howard Owens
Megan Zwerka-Synder Photo by Howard Owens
A Byron-Bergen scoring attempt blocked in the second half. Photo by Howard Owens
Judge Andrea Clattenburg sits at the bench Wednesday n Batavia City Court for the first time after taking the oath of office as part-time City Court Justice. Photo by Howard Owens
Andrea Clattenburg, whose legal career has taken her from a prosecutor's position in the County Attorney's Office to a defense attorney position in the Public Defender's Office, is now a part-time City Court judge.
Clattenburg took the oath of office Wednesday in Batavia City Court in a courtroom packed with family, friends, fellow attorneys, elected officials, and assorted dignitaries.
City Council appointed Clattenburg to the position in August following the resignation of Thomas Burns. City Court judges, state-mandated positions, are elected to six-year terms. Clattenburg will be on an election ballot in November 2026, prior to the expiration of the term Burns vacated. That term expires on Dec. 31, 2026.
Full-time City Court Judge Durin Rogers administered the oath.
"City courts were once described to me as the emergency room or the emergency department," Rogers said. "Many times you don't know what you're gonna have. In City Court, you'd have a traditional vehicle and traffic matter. And for all my former colleagues and for the attorneys, and obviously the judges, you know, that you could have a very serious criminal matter brought into court during vehicle and traffic or during housing, and you have to be able to switch hats. And so you need a keen sense of triage. You need a keen sense of knowledge. And, most importantly, I think judicial temperament, and I'm very excited that we have somebody of Judge Clattenburg's caliber to join us on this team."
Clattenburg thanked her colleagues and family for their support over the years, particularly her father James Clattenburg and her husband Michael Szymczak.
"I grew up in Batavia," Clattenburg said. "I've lived here my entire life. I've worked in Genesee County, in Batavia, my entire life, and I am so thrilled to be able to serve the city of Batavia in this capacity."
During introductions by Rogers, the two newest members of the court staff were also introduced. Kelly Randle is the new chief clerk and Amy VanSplunder is the new deputy clerk.
City Court Judge Durin Rogers administers the Oath of Office to Andrea Clattenburg, the city's new part-time judge. Holding the Bible is her husband, Michael Szymczak, and to her right are her parents James and Marianne Clattenburg. Photo by Howard Owens
Marianne Clattenburg, a member of the Genesee County Legislature, sits in the front row of the City Court gallery with other members of the Clattenburg family. Photo by Howard Owens.
Judge Durin Rogers. Photo by Howard Owens
8th District Administrative Judge Kevin Carter, center. Photo by Howard Owens
Rogers puts her judge's robe on Clattenburg for the first time. Photo by Howard Owens
Judge Durin Rogers, Judge Kevin Carter, 8th District Administrative Judge, Judge Andrea Clattenburg, JaHarr S. Pridgen, City Courts' supervising judge, Judge Melissa Lightcap Cianfrini, County Court, and Judge Tom Williams, Family Court. Photo by Howard Owens.
Elba has a shot at a sectional title in volleyball after the Lancers beat Houghton Academy three sets to zero.
1st game 25 to 18
2nd game 25 to 23
Player stats:
Kennedy Augello 14 assists, 2 kills
Alexa Ocampo 7 kills, 5 digs
Halie Scouten 7 kills, 4 digs
The Lancers will play for the Section V D2 crown at 5 p.m. on Friday at Wayland Cohocton. The match will pit the #6 Lancers against the #1 ranked Avoca-Prattsburgh.
At 7 p.m. on Friday at Wayland Cohocton, in Class D1, #1 seed Alexander players #6 York. Alexander beat Bolivar-Richburg 3-1 on Tuesday.
In Class C1, #2 Le Roy plays #1 Attica at Avon on Friday at 7 p.m. for the title.
The trick-or-treaters were out all over Genesee County. We stopped at the haunted house on Bank Street, Lincoln Avenue, Ellicott Avenue, and Redfield Parkway in the City.
Photos by Howard Owens.
This is Diggs. I made the mistake of asking Diggs, "Have you been getting lots of treats?" He immediately sat and said, "OK, where's my treat?" Photo by Howard Owens.
Isabella Walsh: Section V Class A Player of the Year Isabella Walsh, #11 on the Batavia Blue Devils Girls Soccer team, loves playing defense. She always has.
"I've played defense since I was little," Walsh said. "I like the one-on-one battles and making big saves. I enjoy it."
She's also the team's primary direct-kick specialist (taking kicks following a penalty from outside the penalty box).
These two contributions to Batavia's 14-win season are a big part of why she was named Section V Class A Player of the Year for Girls Soccer.
"I'm really honored to be singled out for this award," Walsh said. "There are so many great players on my team and the teams we compete against. To be a defensive player and to win this type of award is really a great recognition, but this is truly a team award because it's my teammates around me every day in practice and games that make me better and make me want to play harder for them and our team's success."
Batavia's head coach, Roger Hume, said Walsh, now a senior, is a four-year starter at center back, and he doesn't believe she's missed a start in her career.
"She's like the center of our entire defense at this point," Hume said. "She is gonna be a big loss for us."
On the field, Walsh directs the defense when the opposing team has a direct kick or corner kick, and that had a lot to do with Batavia's success in 2023.
"We were at the lowest goal-against total we've had in the last 15 years that I've been here," Hume said. "We had 12 goals against."
Roger Hume Photo by Howard Owens
Roger Hume: Section V Class A Girls Soccer Coach of the Year Fifteen years ago, Roger Hume took over a soccer team that needed new direction. That first year as coach was rough -- no league wins and only a 4-12-1 record on the year. The team scored only 12 goals and gave up 50.
In 2023, he coached the team to a 14-2-1 record, with a team that gave up only 12 goals and scored 73 (The team's previous record for fewest goals against was 17 in 2020 (when the team scored only 15 goals, and the highest goal total was 45 in 2022).
After such a successful season, Hume has been named the Section V Class A Girls Soccer Coach of the Year.
The award isn't just a credit to him, Hume said. It's the entire group of people involved in Batavia Girls Soccer.
"Well, for me, I think it's a combination of all the parents and players that have put the time in, and all of the volunteer coaches and assistant coaches I've had through the years," Hume said. "There's a multitude of parents that had their daughters come up through who helped me from modified all the way up to Varsity. It kind of justifies that we did all that hard work, you know, and it took a while. I mean, 15 years before we had the team -- this has been one of the best teams that we've had, you know, record-wise and group-wise and just the way they are a team together."
Hume now has 111 career wins as a varsity coach.
His soccer career started with his oldest daughter getting involved with soccer when she was four. She's now 32. He became a coach in Batavia Youth Soccer, became a board member, and after a few years, then Athletic Director Mike Bromley asked him if he would coach girls modified soccer for Batavia. After a few years, he moved up to junior varsity and then, 15 years ago, varsity.
The team's biggest improvements have come since the opening of the new Van Detta Stadium with the artificial turf on Woodward Field.
Playing on grass meant playing a slower game, but it also meant, despite all the hard work of the grounds crew, playing on a field that could be a bit uneven.
"When it gets into October, it's tough because it's raining out all the time or it's snowing out all the time," Hume said. "Being able to get on the turf as much as possible has helped to speed up our game a lot. We've really been able to ratchet up."
The proof is the past three years of play against a top Class A team, Pal-Mac. Two years ago, Batavia lost 6-1. Last year, 4-0. This year, in the Class A semifinal, 2-0. That's a measure of progress, even if the Blue Devils haven't yet cleared the hump of beating Pal-Mac.
And the progress doesn't seem to have peaked, Hume indicated.
"We have a great JV group that came up, and I had girls that were freshmen and sophomores that could have been on varsity and would have been on varsity previous years, like five, six years ago, but we didn't have the room for them," Hume said. "They would be playing and I don't want them to sit on the bench if there's no value to it at that point."
Hume acknowledged that as much as it might recognize the success of the program in 2023, it also recognizes the progress of the program.
"I think it is a recognition of what we can do and that we are competitive," Hume said. "We can compete now several teams in our group. Aquinas is in our group, and Pal-Mac is our Class A. Like I said, we did Class A for nine years, and we won four games all the time, or five games all the time, so, you know, I think we're proving we can compete."
Students at Jackson Primary and John Kennedy Intermediate schools went for a trick-or-treat in costume on Tuesday morning, getting treats from police officers, firefighters, bus drivers, and city public works personnel.
The kids at Robert Morris visited a petting zoo, picked out a pumpkin from a pumpkin patch, and enjoyed a snack of doughnut holes and apple cider.
The indoor winter soccer program started on Monday at the YMCA in Batavia, coached by Batavia girls Varsity coach Roger Hume.
He calls the program "club soccer."
It is open to soccer players from third grade through 12th, and it's never too late for a parent to get a child started in the program. Hume said as long as a class has room, the class is open at any time of the winter, November through March, and there is an open registration time again in January.
JV and Varsity players practice and train on Mondays, junior high on Wednesdays, and elementary school kids on Thursdays. On Saturdays, all grade levels participate at different times of the day.
Since many of the JV and Varsity players often play other winter sports, the Monday classes tend to thin out once those seasons start, Hume said.
The session starts with some warm-ups followed by skill work, ball handling.
"We want to do a lot of group stuff, too," Hume said. "Then they'll do some scrimmaging at the end. We try to work on teamwork, try to work on passing, receiving. Indoors is good for more skill work and then some passing, the physicality of the game. But you know, you can't mimic what you're doing outside. I mean, I wish we had turf. Yeah, I always say I wish we had turf, but we don't have turf. So we take advantage of what we have."
In February and March, club players typically participate in tournaments. Batavia, Attica, Keshequa, and Byron-Bergen are among the locations of indoor tournaments.
Two members of a National Grid crew complete a street light replacement on Tuesday morning at Maple Street and Ganson Avenue in the City of Batavia. Photo by Howard Owens
Recently, there have been complaints on social media about residential street lights being out. This morning, The Batavian came across a National Grid crew replacing a light at Maple Street and Ganson Avenue in the City of Batavia.
A crew member said they are replacing all burned-out lights in the city in time for trick-or-treat. At least all they know about -- in this case, today, that's 11.
They only know about a light that needs replacing, he said, if a resident calls in a burned-out light. There are no crews driving around at night looking for burned-out lights, and there is no computer system to inform National Grid of burned-out lights.
He said last week, he was working on a reported 32 lights out in the city. At one stop, a resident asked him if he was going to replace the light "around the corner." He told the resident it wasn't on the list. "Did you call it in?" The resident thought National Grid should already know about it. Again, National Grid only knows if a resident calls it in.
The number to call is the company number on your National Grid bill.
He also said he recently replaced a light on Jackson Street that he knew he had replaced a couple of weeks before. They found a BB-shot hole in the light.
National Grid is responsible for any street lights on a utility pole. If it's not on a utility pole, and it's within the City of Batavia, it is probably the responsibility of the city.
The fact that Jennifer Cobb's birthday and Halloween fall so close together may be why she has such an affinity for the holiday, Cobb conceded during a tour of the haunted house she, her husband, and children created on their property in Bethany.
"My mom always kind of combined them," she said.
For one of her birthdays in her 20s, her mom bought her a casket.
"Every year since I was a little kid, I've enjoyed Halloween," Cobb said. "I've always done big, extravagant things. This year, I decided to go super, super big. In the years past, I've built haunted houses out of my parent's garage and let the public in. I was on the news for that in Buffalo. Then we moved out here and did big huge parties, but I'm like, 'nobody's gonna come out here.' It's too much of a drive, and then we were like, we'll give it a shot, and I hope it's gonna be good. So we'll see. But I love Halloween. I love to scare people."
Her birthday is five days before Halloween.
If you visit the Leising Manor and Graveyard, you will start in the house's dining room, where you will gaze upon a rather macabre dining scene, then you will walk through a haunted kitchen and into the expansive back yard into the trails in the woods where you will find ghouls, goblins, witches, ghosts, cadavers and skeletons among the graveyards scattered among the trees.
Asked why she likes Halloween, Cobb said, "I don't know. I think it's just because it takes people out of their element. Sometimes it makes them really question, 'What drives me, what scares me, what are my fears?' I don't know. I like the gore and the creativity of it. It means something to everybody different. It's just one of them things that you don't have to be a certain religion to like Halloween. You can just like it, you can be young, or old. It doesn't matter. There's no age limit."
The attraction is free, but Cobb said she is asking for donations.
"I'm trying to raise money for a friend who just recently had a fire and lost everything in the fire," she said.
The haunted house is open from 6 to 9 p.m. Sunday, Monday and on Halloween, which is Tuesday. If it rains, Cobb said, "we'll make the best of it." The address is 9772 Bethany Center Road, East Bethany.
Trick-or-treaters were able to visit 28 Downtown businesses on Saturday in an event organized by Michael Marsh of Edward Jones, and all participating businesses purchased their own candy.
Byron-Bergen soccer fans are now celebrating two sectional championships in the same weekend after the boys team defeated #1 seed East Rochester 1-0 for the Class C2 crown.
The lone goal was fired in by forward Jack Farner, with an assist from Colin Martin, in the third minute of the game. Martin MacConnell, along with the Bees defense, held the Bombers scoreless the rest of the match.
Coach Ken Rogoyski said, "The last time that the boys and girls teams were sectional champions in the same year was 2002 (21 years ago). They also both won in 2001. And before that, in 1981 (21 years prior to the 2002 win). Coincidentally, the girls tied their match on Friday, sending them into overtime with 21 seconds left in the game."
The Bees, now 16-2-1, will face Cuba-Rushford/Hinsdale on Wednesday night, location TBD.
Jay Antinore had 240 yards passing for Notre Dame on Saturday to help lead the Fighting Irish to a 20-14 win over Oakfield-Alabama in the Class D Section V quarterfinal.
Antinore completed 11 passes in 15 attempts and connected on TD passes to Jaden Sherwood and Chase Antinore, which was 79 yards in the fourth quarter for the game-winner.
On the ground, Antinore gained 33 yards on 10 carries. He scored one touchdown on the ground.
Chase Antinore had three receptions for 110 yards, and Sherwood had four catches for 73 yards.
On defense, Gabe Castro had 13 tackles, and Scotty McWilliams had 9 1/2.
Senior LB Ashton Bezon - 10 tackles, two forced fumbles, one blocked point-after attempt
Junior WR Jack Cianfrini - 15-Yard Receiving TD
Aggie head coach Tyler Winter said, "With everything this team has had to endure this season, I couldn't be more proud of the way they fought to the very last minute. You could write a book on the adversity they were dealt this fall. They handled themselves with class and integrity amidst it all. The sting of defeat hurts right now, but they will be better young men in the long haul because of it all."
Notre Dame, seeded #5, next faces #1 seed York/Pavilion, time and date to be determined.
A parolee with a lengthy criminal history is in custody following a string of car thefts in Genesee County.
Edward G. Ruckdeschel, 61, of Batavia, is charged with two counts of grand larceny in the third degree and two counts of grand larcenhy in the fourth degree, and could face more changes, according to the Sheriff's Office.
During a lengthy investigation, "several" stolen vehicles were located throughout Genesee County and surrounding areas.
The investigation was conducted by road patrols and criminal investigation divisions with the assistance of the State Police and the Orleans County Sheriff's Office.
Ruckdeschel available criminal record goes back to 1986 when he was arrested in Monroe County and sent to prison, convictions for criminal possession of stolen property 2nd and criminal possession of stolen property first.
In 1997, he was imprisoned for criminal mischief in the third degree and burglary in the third degree.
In 2000 he was sent to prison again on a conviction in Cayuga County for grand larceny in the fourth degree.
In 2006, in Oneida County, burglary in the third degree.
In 2011, criminal possession of stolen property in the third degree and criminal possession of stolen property in the fourth degree.
In 2017, unauthorized use of a motor vehicle in the second degree.
His first conviction to lead to prison time in Genesee County was in 2020 for grand larceny in the fourth degree, auto theft, and grand larceny in the third degree.
Ruckdeschel was arraigned and jailed without bail.
The Sheriff's Office said the investigation is ongoing and Ruckdeschel faces several additional charges.
Byron-Bergen players and fans celebrate their 2023 Class C2 sectional title. Photo by Howard Owens.
Soccer is another game of inches. It's also a game of seconds.
As the clock wound down on Friday night at Gates-Chili, with Byron-Bergen trailing 3-2 in the Girls Soccer Class C2 championship game, a Keshequa Indians player knocked the ball out of the end of the pitch. That made the next play a corner kick. If the ball had gone out of bounds a few more inches to the left, Byron-Beren would have had a throw-in from the side of the field.
On the corner kick, Grace Diquattro struck the ball perfectly, a high, curving shot that Keshequa's keeper managed to touch but not stop as it sailed over her head.
Tie score with 21 seconds left in the regulation time.
It was Diquattro's second goal of the game.
Byron-Bergen won 4-3 on a goal by Makenzie Hagen, assisted by Diquattro, during the fifth minute of overtime.
"The defense had pushed over a lot," said Hagen after the game. "There was a big gap for me to get in, so I called for it, and Grace passed, and we were good to go."
The Indians, the #3 seed entering the tournament, were crushed, while the Bees. #4, celebrated their comeback win near the Keshequa goal.
The win was a special moment for Hagen.
"It's been a crazy experience," she said. "Our team has worked so hard through the seasons to get here and I'm just so proud of us."
The Bees struck first late in the first half on a goal by Mia Gray, with an assist by Diquattro, but Keshequa fired back within two minutes to tie the score at 1-1, which is how the half ended.
In the second half, Diquattro scored her first goal of the game to give Byron-Bergen a 2-1 lead. That goal, too, was a matter of inches, hitting the crossbar before dropping within the area of the goal to count as a score.
But once again, Keshequa answered. This time in about 20 seconds.
Then came Keshequa's third goal. With about four minutes left in the game, Ava Thayer got past the Byron-Bergen defense in space and had a fairly open shot at goal. She didn't miss.
Often in soccer, a one-goal lead is as good as a win with so little time left on the clock.
That's when those precious inches and seconds became so important, and Diquattro became the hero of the moment.
"There's always a bit of luck, right?" said Coach Wayne Hill. "We had luck to score (taking a 2-1 lead). They had luck to come right back down in 20 seconds and score on us right back. They took the lead. I mean, that corner kick was only a corner kick by like three inches. Otherwise, it was a throw, and we've been sunk. So by the grace of God, we got a corner kick. And we scored the tie, and then just the overtime was fantastic."
While it feels great to win in overtime, Hill said he also understands what it's like to be on the other side.
"I was just happy that they fought back and got the tie," Hill said. "That's the best part of overtime, winning. But you always feel horrible for the team that loses in overtime because they deserve to win too. It's a sad, gut-wrenching experience."
Byron-Bergen will next play C1's #1 seed, Holley, at Cal-Mum on either Wednesday or Thursday.
For more photos and to purchase prints, click here.
Grace Diquattro kicking the first of her two goals. Photo by Howard Owens.
Ava Thayer with the goal to put the Indians up 3-2 late in the second half. Photo by Howard Owens.
A save for Byron-Bergen's keeper. Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Photo by Howard Owens.
Makenzie Hagen and Mia Gray celebrate Hagen's winning goal in overtime. Photo by Howard Owens.
This is from a recent edition of an email newsletter published by Investigative Post.
The Batavian has drawn a fair amount of attention over the years for being a successful online, for-profit news organization. What’s been left unsaid is its practice of writing favorable stories about its sponsors and advertisers, in particular, the Western Regional Off-Track Betting Corp. Owner Howard Owens was at it again the week before last, penning another story that echoed the OTB party line (sic on the link).
The Post is a Buffalo-based startup news not-for-profit that doesn't attempt to offer its community complete and comprehensive coverage but rather to cherry-pick the stories it chooses to write.
The publication has been on my radar for a while for its sensationalistic, often incomplete reporting.
Now it is attacking me and my publication, and I think that deserves a public response.
Yes, we're for-profit (though, honestly, it's not that much profit, just enough to keep us in business). And I've known plenty in the nonprofit news sector who consider advertising-supported news to be unethical. Throughout my career, going back to 1986, I've come across no shortage of reporters and editors who thought news should be a charity case.
In 2010, I was in Chicago at the first gathering of small, independent online news publishers. Several of the publishers represented start-up nonprofits. At one session, somebody in the middle of the room stood up and said, "Can we all agree right now that advertising is evil."
I responded by saying essentially that advertising support is far superior to the nonprofit model because you have a greater diversity of revenue. If you're doing it right, no one advertiser is going to be able to hold you hostage. If the need arises to report something negative about a business, you can do so without fear or favor because if that advertiser cancels its promotions, it's not going to put you out of business. It likely won't even mean significant cuts in expenditures. No layoffs. No furloughs. Nobody is hurt.
That diversity of revenue gives us a lot of freedom to report what is factual and honest without succumbing to threats.
I don't give in to blackmail.
For example, by a hard-and-fast policy, we run all arrest reports without favoritism. I've written up arrests of good friends, people I know well and respect. I've had volunteer firefighters, who I have a soft spot for, call me and ask me not to run their arrests. There's no shortage of people calling and asking that we just make this one exception this one time.
But it would be unfair to all the people I don't know, the people who have no connections or advantages or even think to call, to play favorites. We run all arrests we receive from local law enforcement. Period. No exceptions. That has cost us money and hard feelings, no doubt.
Over the past 15 years, three business owners have been arrested (that I know of). In the first case, the advertiser had -- the week before he was arrested -- said he wanted to double his spending with us. The day after we ran news of his arrest, he canceled his ad. He's never advertised with us again. In the second case, the business owner called a staff member and rudely and profanely canceled her ad. In the third case, a friend of the advertiser called me and warned me about running his arrest report. This business owner was a top-tier advertiser. We ran his arrest report the following week when we received it, and he canceled his ad and hasn't run with us since, nor will he again as long as I own The Batavian.
In another case, we ran a story about a local organization that mentioned a newsworthy faux pas by the director. The next time we called for an ad, she said no, citing our previous story.
Look, if an ad buyer has some business reason for not advertising with us and we can't convince that person about why they're wrong, it's the ad buyer's right not to buy an ad from us. But when a buyer tries to blackmail our coverage, that's a line ad buyers are not allowed to cross, as I made clear to this particular ad buyer. We don't change the course of an article to please an advertiser; that's what journalistic integrity is all about.
Batavia Downs Yes, there's no hiding the fact that Batavia Downs is a major advertiser. And yes, we put effort into covering most of the Downs' good news stories (Wiener Dog races, donations, concerts, etc.). Some of this stuff is just fun to cover. And being a comprehensive local news publication, or at least trying, we cover positive events as well as news that is less than favorable to people and places. A news outlet that isn't covering what is good in a community is not serving the community. It's a drain on the community if all the news is negative and sensational, something the folks at Investigative Post clearly don't understand.
I don't think positive stories about local businesses are a bad thing. They are not unethical. Investigative Post seems to disagree, based on the statement above. We cover a lot of business openings. We celebrate significant business anniversaries and expansions. We make it to as many ribbon cuttings as we can. I think successful small businesses are critical to a healthy local community (one of my major complaints about not-for-profit news outlets is they often ignore their locally owned shops, which ill-serves their communities). You will never see positive coverage of locally owned businesses in the Post because, you know, "advertising is evil," which means small business owners don't matter to the "serious journalist."
As for Batavia Downs and what it means to The Batavian: If Western OTB canceled all spending with us, yes, it would hurt. It would hurt a lot. I'd probably cry. But it wouldn't put us out of business, not with our diversified revenue streams (something Early Access Pass is slowly helping with, as well, so please join). If that happened, we would cut back on some spending but nothing that would hurt our employees.
Our main reporter for Western OTB is Mike Pettinella. He's a freelancer, which is ideal in this circumstance because, in accordance with state employment law, I have limited ability to direct his work. He chooses his own stories for the most part (I can suggest stories), and he chooses how to cover them. Investigative Post is making it sound like I cover Western OTB, but I've only ever been to two meetings of the board, and I've done only one significant story about the organization's legal issues. This is by design. I recognize that Batavia Downs is a major advertiser. When Mike is available to cover OTB, his coverage provides a degree of separation between me and that business interest.
Mike is an experienced and professional reporter. He does something that the folks at Investigative Post often fail to do -- he makes sure all sides are represented. He doesn't cherry-pick. He doesn't sensationalize. He just reports the story straight.
It seems the folks at IP think we toe the "OTB party line" (itself a loaded phrase that betrays the Post's bias). No, we just ask Henry Wojtaszek questions and are careful not to misquote him or misrepresent him. Apparently, the folks at IP equate telling a balanced story, letting both sides have their say, with biased coverage. That tells us something about their mindset. Being fair is biased when your view is already made up about a person or entity.
It's almost like they want to try and cower another publication from calling into question their shoddy reporting.
Take, for example, their latest report on Western OTB's legal fees.
The basic presumption of the article is biased, that Western OTB isn't entitled to respond to legal challenges.
Legal challenges that were largely created by the past sensationalistic reporting by IP on Batavia Downs, a fact IP pretty much admits to:
Investigative Post used 2018 as a benchmark for spending on lawyers and lobbyists because OTB operated in relative obscurity until Investigative Post began reporting on its problems that December.
Investigative Post considers mistakes and oversights to be "problems," implying misdeeds in the context of the story. More bias.
An old journalist's trick to justify reporting on something you think should be scandalous is to find somebody to criticize it without full transparency about the source's agenda or finding a way to balance his or her opinion. IP has those sources, an Erie County elected official with a political agenda and a former disgruntled OTB executive. Not that there is anything wrong with giving those people a platform to speak their minds, but knowing up front that they are biased against the target of a story, a fair so-called investigative reporter would seek out sources who might have a different point of view, particularly the chief spokesperson for the agency in question, in this case, Henry Wojtaszek. Of course, Wojtaszek refused to comment on this particular story, but who can blame him, given the IP's history of sensationalizing its coverage of OTB? But surely, the reporter, J. Dale Shoemaker, could have found another legal expert to address the issue that would balance the story, perhaps noting that these expenses are not out of line given what OTB has had to deal with since December 2018.
We now know that Shoemaker could have called City of Rochester OTB representative Dennis Basset for a less sensationalistic take on the legal expenditures, though one suspects that Shoemaker didn't much like Bassett's response to his questions following Thursday's OTB meeting. There are surely other board members who support Wojtaszek who would have shared their views on the matter.
Then there is this quote from Mike Nolan, the former OTB employee, that is presented naked of any meaningful context.
“As a former chief operating officer, the costs that you’re speaking to seem to be extraordinarily high from what they were in years past,” he said.
Well, of course, costs have gone up since Nolan left. He's one of the reasons for higher legal costs since he filed a lawsuit against Western OTB alleging wrongful termination. And since he's left, there have been other questionable attacks on Western OTB that officials there feel the need to defend. Why is it surprising that the agency's legal costs have gone up? And isn't it the right of OTB leadership to defend themselves against what they see as unfair and legally misguided attacks?
Here's their most significant 2018 story reported by IP:
This started the ball rolling on the accusation that the OTB board has illegally or improperly provided itself health care insurance. In the one story I've written on this topic because Mike Pettinella wasn't available, Wojtaszek explained how this issue has been misrepresented. The interview was in response to a now-dismissed lawsuit by George Maziarz (who was represented by another Erie County Democratic politician, Nate McMurray). (It's worth mentioning that this story gave Maziarz his say and allowed Wojtaszek space to respond -- fair and balanced reporting, as it should be done).
As for health insurance for board members, Western OTB has attorneys working on the issue. The agency does not agree that board members can't receive health insurance coverage.
While Maziarz says that the Comptroller's Office and a legal firm hired by Western OTB say the practice is illegal, the issue doesn't appear to be that cut and dry. There is an older Comptroller's opinion that says the practice is permissible. The memo on the topic, prepared by attorneys Gabriel M. Nugent and Robert J. Thorpe for the board, cites the 1978 opinion as well as the later opinion and suggests board members no longer accept health insurance. It doesn't, as Maziarz claims, call the practice illegal.
Health insurance, Wojtaszek said, is justified because pretty much every other public benefit corporation in the state offers it, and Batavia Downs operates in a very competitive environment and needs to attract and retain the most qualified board members.
The other issue addressed by Wojtaszek is the allegations first raised by IP and echoed in the Maziarz suit is the use of free tickets to sporting events.
Batavia Downs acquires tickets as perks for high rollers and special guests, Wojtaszek said. A host from Batavia Downs typically accompanies these guests to the events. The role of the host is to ensure things go smoothly that people get their tickets, get into the venue, receive the service expected for the event, and that the host takes care of any issues that arise.
"Previously, if you were host, we provided a ticket to the host and then the host was allowed to bring a guest with them," Wojtaszek said. "At that point, they may have brought somebody from a wife, a husband, a son, or a daughter with them. We have since corrected that. Subsequent to the recommendation from the compliance company, it's just a host who takes care of whatever event, hockey game, football game, concert, and I think we're doing it properly now."
He said that the accusation that board members could just casually ask for tickets to Bills or Sabres games at board meetings and receive them misrepresents what actually took place. He said anybody, including board members, could ask for tickets on behalf of patrons of Batavia Downs. They were not, he said, asking for themselves and friends and family. However, to help improve the procedure, all requests must now be in writing and clearly state who is receiving the tickets.
There were about 100 tickets unaccounted for, not the thousands previously alleged.
Shoemaker was so eager to push the corruption narrative that he used that loaded word with Bassett in an interview after the board meeting on Thursday.
Clearly, Shoemaker didn't like Bassett's full response to his question because he truncated the key portion of Bassett's quote in his report on the meeting.
"I think corruption is a very strong term," he said. "I've been on this board, as I said, 14 years, and I don't see corruption."
The denial of corruption by a Democrat completely upsets the narrative being pushed by the Post, so of course, Shoemaker didn't include it. Shoemaker's article on the whole overlays and misrepresents Bassett's discussion of "reform." Overall, Bassett concentrated on how well Western OTB is doing and that it is important to stay focused on the business of the operation and its success and not be distracted by politics.
Shoemaker also left out Bassett's statements about changes and reforms already undertaken, instead focusing on potential further "reforms." Again, it would disturb the narrative to report that Wojtaszek and the board have actively responded to criticism and made changes.
If your news business model is to always attack and criticize without ever recognizing the good in people or institutions, then that's a flawed business model. As long as Investigative Post maintains that business model, all it will do is hurt its credibility with fair-minded people while partisans cheer them on, giving them the illusion that they're doing everything right.
It's worth noting that nobody yet, not even the Post, has turned up any evidence of corruption. Mistakes, yes, as Wojtaszek has owned up to, which IP hasn't reported. Throughout five years of constant badgering by IP and others, no illegal activity has been identified. Yes, there is an FBI investigation (which is helping drive up OTB's legal costs), but that has been ongoing for years -- apparently, but the FBI never confirms anything -- and an investigation is not proof of illegal activity. Yet IP throws around the word "corruption" often enough to convince me that the folks there clearly believe OTB is corrupt. In old-school journalism, we call that kind of belief "bias."
GCEDC Based on a prior email conversation with Shoemaker, the folks at Investigative Post also seem to think we pander to GCEDC because GCEDC bought some ads from us. Yes, GCEDC this year -- for the first time -- placed some ads with The Batavian. The entire expenditure is less than one percent of this year's revenue. Yet Shoemaker called into question my ethics. He was ticked that I wouldn't grant him an interview about the ad buy. Why? Because I don't trust the Investigative Post, which I made clear to him.
We've had no issue in the past reporting stories that are unfavorable to GCEDC's agenda. Most notably, we brought attention to GCEDC's plans to use tax incentives for remodeling at Batavia Towne Center. Those design changes would eventually, as expected, lure Dick's Sporting Goods to Batavia. Tax incentives to support retail businesses are a questionable use of an IDA's power since locally owned businesses can be damaged. In fact, both businesses mentioned in the story above are now out of business. I know for a fact that our stories did not please, to put it mildly, the folks over at GCEDC.
Tainted Money So let's return to the for-profit vs. not-for-profit debate.
I've encountered the arrogance of nonprofit publishers many times over the past 15 years. They think that because they are not driven by profit in capitalist terms, their motivations are pristine. And that is their blind spot. All news organizations need to bring in more revenue than they spend and set some aside for inevitable revenue shortfalls when business cycles take a dive, as financial disclosures show Investigative Post does.
Here's the thing though: All money is tainted in some way. The need to raise money to fund journalism doesn't isolate the publication's leaders from pressure to shade coverage. It doesn't matter if you operate with a profit motive or without. As Bob Dylan sang, "You've got to serve somebody."
If you rely on advertising, you might be tempted to bend to an advertiser's will (though, as I explain above, this is less likely, but I have seen it happen). If all of your revenue comes from readers, either through subscriptions or memberships, then you will be more likely to cater to the will of the readers, who don't always see the full picture or have a balanced view of the world. For example, if you're a publisher in a largely progressive Democratic community, you're going to be hard-pressed to publish stories that run against that orthodoxy. If nothing else, you'll be less welcome at swank cocktail parties. And, finally, if all your revenue comes from donors, you're going to be beholden to your largest donors.
If most of your donors are institutional -- meaning big annual grants -- you're only going to get grants if your operations conform to the foundation's political ideology if they have one, and in my experience, many do, either left or right, because that's why they get into the business of handing out money -- to push agendas.
Investigative Post reported $434,875 in donations in 2022. Jim Heaney, the founder, editor and executive director, was paid more than $70,000. That isn't exorbitant for his leadership position, but clearly, he needs the Investigative Post to be successful if he wants to continue earning that salary in an era when good-paying journalism jobs are hard to come by.
The Post lists among its major donors some fairly progressive, left-leaning funders, such as the Wallace Global Fund, the Rowboat Family Foundation, and the Knight Foundation (this might surprise some, but I have personal experience dealing with that foundation's agenda-driven contributions in another organization where I served on the board).
These potential ties to Democratic donors, and the need to pander to mostly Democratic Erie County, are important to think about because the reporting of the Post has helped lead the the disenfranchisement of the rural counties that are members of the OTB board of directors. Earlier this year, Democratic State Sen. Tim Kennedy of Buffalo pushed through legislation that weighted the OTB board voting in favor of the Democratic-dominated counties of Monroe, Niagara and Erie.
For the Investigative Post, mission accomplished, perhaps. The problem is the current board seems to favor Monroe County's Bassett, who seems to support Wojtaszek, as its new chair, with one notable exception. Erie County's board member Jennifer Hibit blocked Bassett's appointment to chair.
Isn't it interesting that an Erie County Democrat, Sen. Kennedy, wrote legislation to put enough power in the hands of Erie County's Democrats that one OTB member can thwart the will of the rest of the board, including non-Erie County Democrats? A more cynical and conspiracy-minded person (and I hate conspiracy theories) would suspect that Erie County Democrats, aided and abetted by the Investigative Post, are trying to angle to gobble up more of the revenue generated by Batavia Downs. Legally that might be difficult, but way less difficult for Erie County Democrats to pull off is selling Batavia Downs to the Seneca Nation or the politically connected Delaware North (where Gov. Kathy Hochul's husband works UPDATE: A couple of days after publication I was informed Bill Hochul recently left Delaware North). Don't be surprised if there is pressure from the governor's office on Monroe County to remove Bassett from the OTB board. Would Heany and Shoemaker call that corruption?
And don't expect the Investigative Post to question the motives of the Democratic Party when it comes to Western OTB.
Savarino and Elliott Station If the Post isn't just about pushing a political agenda and really, truly, about investigating questionable conduct, why hasn't it written anything about Sam Savarino and Savarino Companies?
Savarino is one of Buffalo's most prominent developers and has been involved in multiple projects supported by taxpayer dollars, which is normally just the kind of target the Post likes.
As The Batavian has pretty much exclusively reported -- Ellicott Station was sold to the community first as market-rate housing, then as workforce housing, only to find out it was really intended to be very low-income housing with subsidized rents. The Investigative Post has called into question our relationship with GCEDC, but that reporting by Joanne Beck led to a less-than-pleasant phone call from a GCEDC official. Of course, we knew our reporting would upset some people locally, but we did it anyway because it was the right thing to do.
Since then, Savarino Companies has gone out of business. The result, apparently, of questionable dealings with Alfred State and New York State, leaving, we're told, multiple projects incomplete, including Ellicott Station.
This is surely a situation that begs for more investigative reporting. We're doing our best to push hard on the Ellicott Station issue, the only news organization to do so, even though we must rock some boats in the process, but we don't have the resources to commit to a major investigative project. A developer of Savarino's history certainly has a deep and long paper trail an investigative reporter could explore. I would love to do it, but I wouldn't be able to cover soccer and basketball games, school board meetings, planning board meetings, town board meetings, community events, and other such news that I'm sure Heany finds beneath his dignity. All my time would be taken up by digging through Savarino documents and ferreting out sources.
Meanwhile, the Investigative Post is generating substantially more revenue than we are, has a much larger staff with only one charge -- digging up dirt -- and they're letting Sam Savarino off the hook. Why?
My only guess is it has something to do with Savarino being a major contributor to Investigative Post and sitting on the board of directors.
Talk about a conflict of interest for Heaney. He's living in quite the glass house, but he wants to throw stones at me.
