batavia

Building an "inclusive playground" at Kiwanis Park in the Town of Batavia will cost $125,000, members of the Batavia Kiwanis Club were told at their weekly meeting today.

The group backing the project has already raised $30,000, asked the club to pitch in $10,000 and is making similar requests of a number of local groups.

Susan Maha, who is on the committee helping to bring the idea of an inclusive park to fruition, told members "it's your park" and the Kiwanis should be part of the project.

An inclusive park includes play sets that are accessible to people with disabilities, whether physical or mental.

"So many kids in our community have these fears and can't go to a normal playground," Maha said. "We have thousands of people in our community who can't go to a normal playground and it breaks my heart."

The playground would be open to the entire community, young and old, with disabilities or not.

Maha recalled the history of the park, which was first proposed in 1976. The Kiwanis helped raise $100,000 and the park opened in 1982.

Shelley Falitco, director of development for Genesee ARC, said backers have until March 1 to raise the $125,000. That's when the playground equipment must be ordered so it arrives by April's "Day of Caring."

The group will be looking for 50 people to volunteer on the Day of Caring to help install the playground equipment.

To find out how to support the project, contact Shelley Falitco at (585) 343-1123.

Top photo, Shelley Falitco; inset photo, Susan Maha.

Supporters of Genesee ARC are planning a rally at 6:15 p.m., Monday, outside Batavia City Hall, to voice support of the agency, which may lose its garbage collection contract with the city.

The city council will hold a public hearing at 7 p.m. on proposed changes to local laws governing garbage collection.

The changes are necessary to institute an automated tote collection system.

Genesee ARC, which has collected trash in the city for nearly 30 years, submitted the highest bid for the new contract.

Press release:

The City of Batavia Professional Firefighters Association recently donated $1,000 to Genesee Cancer Assistance. The money was generated from the annual breast cancer awareness campaign T-shirt sales. The firefighters association would like to thank the community for its support of such a worthy cause.

A Batavia resident accused of committing crimes while reportedly under the influence of bath salts over the summer avoided a felony conviction Wednesday after a Genesee County jury found him not guilty of the higher charges.

Bradley C. Broadbent was found guilty on five misdemeanor counts, but by avoiding the felony convictions he is no longer looking at up to 15 years in prison as a second felony offender.

The jury found Broadbent guilty of two counts of criminal mischief, 4th, two counts of criminal trespass, 2nd, and petit larceny.

He was acquitted on the charges of criminal trespass, 3rd, and second-degree burglary.

Last month Broadbent turned down a plea deal and elected to take his chances with a jury.

Because the 32-year-old Broadbent has a prior violent felony conviction, the best deal District Attorney Lawrence Friedman could offer Broadbent was a minimum of five years in prison with a guilty plea to attempted burglary, 2nd, a Class D felony.

Broadbent was accused of breaking into bathrooms of a building on Liberty Street one day in July and later that day he reportedly climbed atop a roof on Hutchins Street and needed emergency responder assistance to be talked off it. That night, he reportedly escaped from UMMC's emergency room and was accused of breaking into a home on Tracy Avenue.

Broadbent's family spoke with the media at the time about his arrest because they were concerned that bath salts had derailed his attempt to get his life back in order after getting out of jail on a previous charge.

Brian P. Griffen is indicted on counts of burglary, 3rd, and grand larceny, 4th, and four times since October he's appeared before Judge Robert C. Noonan to answer to those charges.

Four times Griffen's attorney has been missing in action, according to Noonan.

Today, the judge told Griffen it's time for him to find a new attorney.

According to documents, Griffen is represented by David S. Widenor, a Buffalo-based defense attorney.

Griffen told Noonan he's paid Widenor $800 to represent him.

According to court staff, Widenor has never denied representing Griffen and Assistant District Attorney Will Zickl said he's received written correspondence from Widenor about the Griffen case.

Noonan said he's written to Widenor and told him he better make his next court appearance (which was today) or there could be financial consequences.

On at least one occasion, Widenor reportedly told Noonan that he forgot to record Griffen's court appearance on his calendar.

"I can't just leave this case on the calendar until someday he decides to grace me with his presence," Noonan said.

Zickl told Noonan, "(Griffen) has been here every time he's been directed to be here. We certainly support his realization that perhaps he needs another attorney."

Griffen was indicted in October and accused of breaking into a building on Fisher Road, Oakfield, sometime between June 12 and June 26 and stealing a dune buggy, Yamaha Kodiak 4-wheeler and a Honda dirt bike.

Under questioning from Noonan, Griffen said he has a job. He didn't ask for a court-appointed attorney. He said he has missed work to make his court appearances, which brought a sad shake from Noonan.

Noonan said that if Griffen files a grievance with the bar association that might be the best way for Griffen to get his $800 back. Noonan said he couldn't wait, however, for Griffen to get reimbursed before he retains another attorney.

Noonan ordered Griffen back in court March 6.

Whether Griffen files a grievance (about his attorney's absenteeism), Noonan said, is entirely up to him.

Five Star Bank has reimbursed $6,600 to Austin's Army -- a fundraising effort to assist a Pembroke teen struck with a rare form of cancer -- after a local woman allegedly made unauthorized withdrawals from the charitable account.

The alleged theft was discovered by Jason Heineman on Nov. 27.

Jodi M. Coe, 37, of Batavia Oakfield Townline Road, Oakfield, was arrested in connection with the alleged theft and charged with 41 counts of possessing a forged instrument.

According to court documents, Coe allegedly acquired blank checks, drafted the checks in her name and forged Jason Heineman's signature on the checks.

Heineman wrote in an affidavit that he never wrote checks to Coe out of the Austin Army's account and that she was never authorized to write checks to herself.

The checks were all allegedly cashed between Oct. 7 and Nov. 5, while Heineman was in New York City with his son, Austin, who was in NYC for surgery and treatment.

The bank balance discrepancy was discovered by Heineman when he visited a Five Star branch in Dansville and needed to transfer funds to another account.

Upon requesting an account summary, Heineman noticed checks being cashed out of sequence. 

When confronted with an accusation by Heineman, Coe allegedly said she had a problem and was in over her head.

Later she allegedly told Heineman that she had a gambling problem.

According to documents, Heineman gave Coe an opportunity to reimburse the account and when that allegedly did not happen by Dec. 5 he contacted the Sheriff's Office.

Coe faces 36 counts in Batavia City Court of possession of a forged instrument and another five counts in the Town of Le Roy.

She is jailed without bail.

If convicted, Coe would likely be required to pay restitution and that restitution would be paid to Five Star Bank.

Austin Heineman still has ongoing medical expenses and anybody wishing to make a donation can contact Five Star Bank.

While the case will remain open, State Police investigators have been unable to obtain sufficient evidence so far to make an arrest in the case of a shot fired in the Walmart parking lot Jan. 21.

Investigator Kenneth Dubrinski said that even though there is a video of the incident, the one person possibly involved whom investigators could identify is uncooperative.

The video is not of good enough quality to release pictures in the hopes of identifying other individuals, Dubrinski said.

"You can barely make out the make and model of the car," he said.

Last week, police learned that a car that was parked in the area at the time was struck by a bullet.

The bullet could not be recovered.

Dubrinski said even though there isn't much new to report on the case, the case will remain open for some time in case somebody comes forward with new information.

"This is a little more serious than a run-of-the-mill case and we don't want to close it until we know we have everything covered," Dubrinski said.

As for the possibility of one or more people involved having ties to a criminal gang, Dubrinski said, "that would be speculation."

Jodi M. Coe, 37, of Batavia Oakfield Townline Road, is charged with 36 counts of criminal possession of a forged instrument, 2nd, in the City of Batavia and five counts of criminal possession of a forged instrument, 2nd, in the Town of Le Roy. Coe was allegedly in possession of numerous checks containing forged signatures. Coe allegedly possessed the checks while at various locations within the City of Batavia and Town of Le Roy. Following arraignment in city court, Coe was ordered jailed without bail. Town of Batavia Court set her bail at $5,000 cash or $10,000 bond.

Cassi Ann Schutt, 25, of West Crest Drive, Rochester, is charged with petit larceny. Schutt is accused of stealing $328.23 in merchandise from Kmart. When confronted by Kmart security, Schutt allegedly fled on foot. She was apprehended in the Tops parking lot after a brief foot chase. State Police assisted in the arrest. Investigation by Deputy Tim Wescott.

Rodney Lowee McKenzie, 48, of Buffalo, is charged with inhalation of hazardous inhalants. McKenzie was allegedly observed snorting inhalants while seated in a car in the Flying J parking lot. McKenzie was arrested by Deputy Patrick Reeves.

From Tom Houseknecht:

There is one major problem with Mr. Molino’s most recent attempt to sell city council and the voters of Batavia on removing garbage collection from the budget and replacing the tax with a user fee. In his comparison of costs, he claims that maintaining the current trash system would require a property tax increase from the current $10.71 to $11.14 per thousand. What he does not tell anyone in this comparison is that this increase cannot happen without a public vote by the citizens of Batavia (with 60% in favor) because of New York’s 2% property tax cap. This means $10.92 is the highest the tax rate can rise to without a vote of the citizens. Many more cuts would be needed in the city budget to keep the taxes under the cap, perhaps including council’s 75% pay increase.

What I feel is happening in this change of trash/recycling collection is this – If Mr. Molino removes the trash process from the budget (effectively lowering the budget by approximately one million dollars) he is able to avoid dealing with a property tax increase of more than 2%. An increase higher than 2% would cause council to put the city’s budget out to public vote. The only other way to keep the tax rate below a 2% increase would be to make big cuts elsewhere. The biggest perceived adverse side affect to this proposal is the impact on the ARC as their collection system, that has served the city well for 28 years, is not geared to the new user fee based system. Therefore, with little time in which to craft their response to the city’s bid specification, the ARC was not the lowest bidder.

With the sideshow of the battle for the ARC and the local jobs they provide, Mr. Molino has attempted to paint his new proposal as an overall savings for the taxpayers. The problem is that we are being misled into thinking that the majority of taxpayers will experience lower costs. The reality is the lowest valued properties will pay an increased amount and the highest valued properties will receive the savings, while the majority of taxpayers will pay more in total.

I now believe that the main reason for this proposal is that it allows for minimal budget cuts, a city council raise and no public vote while passing the bulk of the increase onto the city’s lowest income citizens. When compared to what you paid in 2012, if you are assessed at $60,000, the increase in what you pay out between your taxes and the new user fee at the smallest tote size will be an additional $64 per year, however if you are assessed at $200,000 you will save $183.

Under the proposed plan, everyone assessed below $96,000 will be paying more than they did in 2012. Everyone assessed higher will receive a savings. This break-even point on assessment will move somewhat if a higher tax rate is considered as opposed to the proposed rate with user fee, but should not be compared to a rate that is higher than the city will be allowed to pass without a vote of the citizens.

I’m not disputing the fact that trash collection is an expensive service that needs to be scrutinized as part of the budgeting process. I’m also not opposed to a pay increase for council members. What I take exception to is the ruse that a user fee based system will save the majority of taxpayers money. The “Fact” sheet on the city’s own Web site makes the ludicrous claim that “close to 90% of the city's properties will experience lower costs.” Whether this is a distortion, a misrepresentation, a mistake or a lie, it is far from the truth. If it is true that the average home is assessed at $80,000.00 (as quoted from Mr. Molino’s budget presentation of 1/7/10), the majority of city taxpayers will be paying more. Whether you call it a user fee or a property tax, it is a tax that will impact those who can least afford it the most.

The trash collection/user fee issue is a ruse for the fact that the city is currently proposing an overall budget that will cause them to exceed the 2 percent property tax cap. Their proposed solution puts a greater burden on the city’s lowest income residents, grants council a 75% salary increase and throws one of our finest local human service agencies and their employees under the bus. The plan is being promoted with distortions of fact. All residents need to hold council and the city manager accountable.

As this is my second letter regarding this issue, I again want to state that I appreciate the efforts of our city leaders, especially in these trying economic times. My purpose in writing is not to attack the service of our council members, but to suggest that the facts are being presented in a way that may not be clearly understood by all taxpayers. I am a proponent of the ARC and I believe they are caught in this controversy because of city management’s goal to remove trash collection from the property tax in an effort to avoid a budget battle.

Thomas Houseknecht

I think the person going behind me on Harvester Avenue got a little irritated when I suddenly slowed this afternoon. I did go forward and turn around and come back.  It's not like I haven't taken photos of the Richmond Mausoleum before, but I was struck by the way the light was hitting it around 3:30 p.m.

About 50 downtown business owners and managers gathered this morning in the community center of City Church to learn more about the activities of the Business Improvement District.

Part of the goal of the program was to encourage more people to volunteer on BID committees.

Committees are:

• Business Development Committee, chaired by Anthony Condello (pictured above)
• Design Committee, chaired by Victor Gautieri, (second picture)
• Promotion Committee, chaired by Mary Valle
• Organization/Executive Group, chaired by Paul Marchese (bottom photo)
• Visioning Commitee, chaired by James Isaac

Marchese unveiled a new mission statement and vision statement for the BID.

Mission Statement:

The Batavia Business Improvement District promotes and enhances the unique experience of shopping, working, and living in downtown Batavia.

Community begins downtown!

Vision Statement:

More Feet Downtown!

This photo is actually from yesterday afternoon: City workers Kevin Hamilton and Shawn McAlister were working downtown, replacing the banners on light poles.

Jonathan Enrique Garcia, 20, of West Main Street Road, Batavia, is charged with possessing a sexual performance of a child. A probation search allegedly turned up images of a nude, juvenile female on Garcia's mobile phone.

Nathan P. Crawford, 17, of 114 Hutchins St., Batavia, is charged with grand larceny, 3rd. Crawford was arrested following an investigation into a report of jewelry and electronics missing from a residence on Jackson Street, Batavia. The items were allegedly taken from the home between September and December. The value of the items exceeds $3,000. Crawford was released under supervision of Genesee Justice.

Faith Brenda Obeirne, 45, of Mount Read Boulevard, Rochester, is charged with petit larceny and criminal possession of a controlled substance. Obeirne was turned over to Sheriff's Office custody upon release from the City of Rochester Jail on a warrant out of Town of Batavia Court. Obeirne was jailed on $500 bail.

Shawn Michael Twardowski, 30, of Dodd Run Road, Marietta, Ohio, was arrested on warrants for alleged criminal contempt, 1st, and aggravated harassment, 2nd. Twardowski was taken into custody in Caldwell, Ohio, and transported back to New York. He was jailed on $100,000 bail.

Kristianna Lynn Thornton, 29, of Pierce Avenue, Niagara Falls, Thornton was arrested on a bench warrant out of Town of Batavia Court for alleged failure to appear. She was jailed on $250 bail.

Tonya Marie Weber, 28, West Main Street, Batavia, is charged with two counts of endangering the welfare of a child. Weber is accused of leaving her children with a person unfit to care for them. When contacted by law enforcement and instructed to return home and care for her children, Weber allegedly did not return. The children were allegedly neglected. The investigation was conducted by Deputy Kevin McCarthy, Deputy Chad Minuto, Trooper Holly Hansel and Trooper Bryman and DSS.

Pauly's Pizza will reopen in a couple of weeks, according to co-owner Paul Berardini.

The restaurant closed today for two reasons, Berardini said. First, it's time for some remodeling -- and the dead of winter is a good time to do it -- and the doctor ordered some rest for Berardini to take care of a minor medical issue.

In a couple of weeks, customers can expect a "healthy owner," a fresh cleaning, a new fryer hood and some equipment changes, Berardini said.

Police in the Town of Amherst have arrested three people who are suspected in a series of commercial burglaries in the region.

Among the items recovered were two air compressors that the suspects allegedly said may have come from a location or locations in the Batavia area.

If you have any information related to these possibly stolen air compressors, contact Investigator Kris Kautz in the Genesee County Sheriff's Office at (585) 345-3000, ext. 3571.

Plans to upgrade Kiwanis Park, on West Main Street Road in the Town of Batavia, to become an "inclusive park" (one that accommodates children and adults with disabilities) continue to move forward.

Local community members have been meeting recently, planning the process and starting the fundraising.

One of the first steps is the creation of a Facebook page in support of the project. Go like it.

Previously: Town of Batavia looking at upgrading Kiwanis Park to accommodate children with disabilities

By a one-vote margin, the Batavia City Council voted to raise its annual pay by $1,500, from $2,000 a year to $3,500.

The pay increase was approved by the council last year, but Councilman Pierluigi Cipollone (inset photo) offered a motion to amend the proposed budget for 2012-2013 to delete the increase in pay.

His motion failed on a 4-5 vote with Cipollone, Brooks Hawley, Kris Doeringer and Patti Pacino backing the no-raise motion.

"I have had people come to me, and say, 'you are going to give yourself a raise on top of all this. It’s not deserved,' " Cipollone said. "I didn't take this job for the money."

Doeringer said increasing council pay is moving service on the council into a career, not community service.

"I don’t want to make the council positions about money," Doeringer said. "We didn't take the seats to make money. We're not career politicians. We all do something on the outside. I don’t want to see the City of Batavia move to where people want to be on council because they think it’s a job."

Councilman John L. Canale (bottom photo) noted that he voted agaisnt the raise last year because he felt it was too soon after seating a new council to be making that kind of decision.

Since then, he said, the council has proven to the public it deserves the raise.

"I said I would have the full intention of voting myself a raise this year if as a team we could prove to the constituents that we can do the job," Canale said. "I think in the last year, especially with the freshman that were on the council, along with the experienced ones, I think we have well proven to the general public that we can work as a cohesive unit."

He said the proposed budget, with a 16-percent decrease in taxes, is proof of the bipartisan nature of the council.

Councilwoman Rose Mary Christian said that what she hears from constituents is that council members should be paid more.

"I don’t know who you talk to, but there are people I talk to who say we don’t get enough for the crap we have to go through," Christian said.

City Manager Jason Molino informed council members Monday night that he's found another 2.17-percent savings in the city's 2012-2013 budget.

He also shared how he believes some city residents will save money under the proposed changes in garbage collection service.

Molino also proposed making a first-year commitment of $45,000, taken from reserve funds, to back community enhancement plans put forward by the Vibrant Batavia committee.

The new proposed tax rate is $8.95 per thousand of assessed value, which is a 16.42-percent decrease from the 2011-2012 tax rate of $10.71.

For a property owner with an assessed value of $80,000, that is $140.80 savings in tax payments.

As part of the budget presentation during the workshop meeting last night, Molino shared figures based on Batavia's average assessed value for single family homes of $92,000 that showed such a homeowner would save money with proposed changes to the garbage collection service.

City staff is proposing a switch to an automated tote system -- residents would wheel totes out to the curb and a one-man garbage collection truck would drive by and use a lift to pick up the tote and dump trash into the truck.

The lowest bidder to take over the garbage collection under the new system is Allied, based in Arizona. If Allied is awarded the bid, it would end nearly 30 years of garbage collection in Batavia by Genesee ARC.

The actual projected savings are based on Molino's contention that taxes will have to go up if the current program with ARC is continued into 2012-2013.

To continue the current garbage collection system, taxes would need to go up to $11.14 per thousand, Molino said.

He said for a home assessed at $92,000, the property owner would pay $823,40 for a 35-gallon refuse tote. The refuse fee would be $169 annually for a total spent on property taxes and garbage collection of $992.40.

For 2011-2012, that property owner is paying $985.32 in a single bill that covers property taxes with garbage included, so the new system would cost $7.08 more.

However, Molino said the tax rate cannot remain at $10.71 if the council elects to keep ARC without the totes.

The tax rate would have to go up to $11.14, making the tax levy for that $92,000 home $1,024.88 -- or $39.56 over this year's taxes.

Using those numbers, the person who owns a $92,000 home would save $32.48 with a 35-gallon tote. The homeowner would save $3.48 with a 96-gallon tote (which has a refuse fee of $198 annually).

Here's a charge looking at various options:

Assessed Value Current tax of $10.71 $8.95 + $169 Fee Tax Rate of $11.14 $70,000 $749.70

$795.50

$779.80 $80,000 $856.80 $885.00 $891.20 $92,000 $985.32 $992.40 $1,024.88 $105,000 $1,124.55 $1,108.75 $1,169.70 $120,000 $1,285.20 $1,243.00 $1,336.80 $160,000 $1,713.60 $1,601.00 $1,782.40 $200,000 $2,142.00 $1,959.00 $2,228.00 $250,000 $2677.50 $2,406.50 $2,785.00

Councilwoman Patti Pacino said she's had constituents raise the issue with her that they don't understand why the city is projecting an increase in garbage collection costs when ARC hasn't been raising their prices.

Molino said the increase is due to annual hikes in the tipping fee costs for refuse disposal at a facility in Riga.

CORRECTION: Molino said ARC has raised rates over the past five years.

Councilman Jim Russell asked why the city has separate contracts for garbage collection and garbage disposal and Molino said the arrangement is unusual, but it was put in place decades ago.

Typically, Molino said, there's just one contract with a refuse collection company, because such a company can usually get better rates from waste facilities (be they dumps or incinerators) because of the greater volume one collection company generates over multiple jurisdictions.

Buying the totes will cost the city about $500,000. The city will borrow the money on what's called a "bond anticipation note." Such a financial scheme allows the city up to five years to pay back the loan or it must issue a bond. The cost of the totes are built into the user fee and will be paid back through the user fee within five years.

The totes have a 10-year warranty, but on average, they should last 15 years, even in Batavia.

Once the totes are paid for, the council will have a decision about what to do with the extra fee being charged -- lower the rate, save it for buying new totes in future years, or a combination of both.

On the issue of Vibrant Batavia: The council will be asked to pass a measure that will create an official committee and fund the projects of Vibrant Batavia for $45,000 for the first year.

Vibrant Batavia is being asked to increase its fundraising commitment from $22,000 to $27,000.

Vibrant Batavia is a community development program that will work on neighborhood revitalization, marketing the city and planning for the city's centennial celebration.

Initially, Vibrant Batavia requested $50,000 a year for three years. The council will review the progress of Vibrant Batavia after the first year and decide whether to fund it further.

"If it goes well, then you're second and third year discussions will be easier," Molino said. "If it doesn't go well, you discontinue it."